Wednesday 24 Oct 2018

stovall-np-banner-final-2octjpg

Judge Slashes $50M Penalty Against Pork Giant

RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — A federal judge has slashed $50 million in damages that a jury awarded neighbors of an industrial hog operation in order to punish a pork producer for smells and noise so bad that people couldn’t enjoy their rural homes.

U.S. District Judge W. Earl Britt ruled this week that North Carolina law required him to cut the size of punitive damages to $2.5 million total for the 10 plaintiffs. Attorneys for the homeowners did not respond Wednesday to requests for comment.

Britt cited state law that limits the punishment for corporate misdeeds to no more than $250,000, an amount 1/20th the $5 million that jurors last month ordered Smithfield Foods to pay each neighbor. Neighbors of a 15,000-head Bladen County swine operation also were awarded $75,000 each in compensation for conditions that prevented them from enjoying their own property.

Plaintiffs’ attorneys had argued the state’s cap on punitive damages was unconstitutional because it violates the right to a jury trial. However, attorneys for the neighbors recognized they were asking Britt to rule contrary to a 2004 state Supreme Court decision that determined that limiting how heavily misdeeds could be punished was no barrier to a jury deciding who was at fault.

“The jury’s role in awarding punitive damages can be dictated by our state’s policy-making body, the General Assembly, without violating plaintiffs’ constitutional right to trial by jury,” Britt wrote in his order filed Monday.

The decision was the first in dozens of lawsuits filed by more than 500 neighbors complaining about hog operations.

North Carolina legislators last year changed state law to make it much more difficult to replicate such nuisance lawsuits targeting hog operations.

Smithfield Foods called the lawsuits “a serious threat” to its North Carolina livestock operations and related jobs. The company has said it would appeal last month’s jury decision.

Lawyers targeted the hog-production division of Virginia-based Smithfield Foods — not the Bladen County farm’s owner — because they said the Chinese-owned company uses strict contracts to dictate how farm operators raise livestock that Smithfield owns.

The judge’s order is unlikely to affect the upcoming negligence lawsuits targeting North Carolina hog operations because jurors aren’t told their award could be capped, Wake Forest University law professor Sidney Shapiro said. That’s because if jurors knew the law limited damages that are meant as punishment, they might inflate how much they award in compensation.

Shapiro thinks Britt’s order might be appealed since it doesn’t address that the Smithfield Foods neighbors complained about nuisances that show no signs of stopping as long as industrial-scale hog operations keep their current method of waste handling.

“The plaintiffs argued that the punitive damages were necessary as a deterrent,” he said, “that it was necessary for the jury to indicate to the defendants that their wanton behavior, if continued, would continue to endanger the plaintiffs’ property. That’s the argument that the judge didn’t deal with one way or the other.”

Rural residents have complained about smells, clouds of flies and excessive spraying for decades. But local and state politicians have either supported the politically powerful industry or backed down in the face of its clout.

Smithfield Foods hasn’t changed the locally dominant method of hog waste disposal since intensive hog operations multiplied in North Carolina in the 1980s and ’90s. The practice involves housing thousands of hogs together, flushing their waste into holding pits, allowing bacteria to break down the material, then spraying the effluent onto fields with agricultural spray guns.

Neighbors say the spraying sends the smells and animal waste airborne, allowing it to drift into their homes and sometimes coat outdoor surfaces on their properties.

Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

3 Comments

  1. Kama says:

    Sure does sound like the ‘Good ‘Ol Boys’ in usual form.. but hey, that’s the ‘smell of money’ to ALL of those involved on the farm side, right.. by golly.

    Reply
  2. Why! says:

    Are these families going to use the money to move away from the hog farms? If not, they shouldn’t receive any money because nothing is going to change! Smithfield and other hog farms have very strict governmental regulations that they must follow! I have no doubt that all regulations are being followed! If a person wants to live in the country then they must take what country living includes! SMH..PURE GREED!

    Reply
    • Yourekiddingme says:

      I agree. This jury is just using this situation as a whipping post to set a precedence for other whining people to follow. If you don’t like living in the country with all it’s smells, flies, chickens crowing, cows mooing, opposums in the yard at night, and chicken snakes… you need to take that ill-earned money and move.

      Reply

Leave a Comment

GoldsboroDailyNews.com welcomes and encourages all our users to contribute and voice their opinions. We do not discriminate against any political or ideological views. In order to maintain a civil discussion, the following guidelines will be adhered to:

1.Profanity is not allowed. Comments containing anything that is deemed profane may be deleted entirely.
2.Hate speech will not be tolerated. Comments against a person based on their race, religion, sexual orientation, gender, etc. may be deleted entirely.
3.Threats will not be tolerated. Comments threatening harm or violence to a person or persons may be deleted entirely.

Goldsboro Daily News staff reserves the right to approve, edit, or delete any comments as they see fit based upon these guidelines. User-submit views and comments do not necessary reflect the views and opinions of staff and management of GoldsboroDailyNews.com.